A Lodestar To Steer The Economy 
| Parakala Prabhakar, Economist, Hyderabad - 15 Oct 2019

Parakala, Finance Minister's Husband Hits out at Centre Over Economic Slowdown 

Parakala, noted economist and Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman’s husband says Centre is in ‘denial mode’ about the economic slowdown.

“The party (BJP) mainly adopted ‘Neti Neti (Not this, Not this’), without articulating what was its own ‘Niti (policy)’, wrote Parakala Prabhakar, in an op-ed article, titled “A lodestar to steer the economy”, published in leading English Daily ‘The Hindu’ on Oct 14, 2019. He also criticised the Bharatiya Janata Party for rejecting the Nehruvian economic framework. It said the ruling party “fails to realise” that their attacks were more of “a political assault” and not economic critique. “

“There is anxiety all over about the economic slowdown in the country,” Prabhakar wrote. “While the government is still in denial mode, data flowing uninterruptedly into the public domain show that sector after sector is staring at a seriously challenging situation.” Parakala Prabhakar, a well known economist, who was earlier a communications adviser to the Andhra Pradesh government, said the Centre was yet to figure out a solution for what “ails the economy”, and claimed “less evidence” is available to even believe that it has a “strategic vision” to address the problems. Prabhakar pointed out India’s GDP growth rate slipped to a six-year low of 5% in the April-June quarter and unemployment was at a 45-year high.

Here is his full article, published in The Hindu.

A Lodestar To Steer The Economy


There is anxiety all over about the economic slowdown in the country. While the government is still in denial mode, data flowing uninterruptedly into the public domain show that sector after sector is staring at a seriously challenging situation. Private consumption has contracted and is at an 18-quarter low of 3.1%; rural consumption is in a deep southward dive and is double the rate of the urban slowdown; credit off-take by micro and small industries remains stagnant; net exports have shown little or no growth; GDP growth is at a six-year low with the first quarter of FY20 registering just 5%; and unemployment is at a 45-year-high. The government, however, is yet to show signs that it has come to grips with what ails the economy. Much less evidence is available to believe that it has a strategic vision to address the challenges.

No economic road map

The problem is rooted mainly in the BJP’s inexplicable reluctance, over the years, to develop its own coherent set of ideas about the country’s economy. The rejection of Nehruvian ‘socialistic pattern of society’ was clear since the days of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh. The BJP’s advocacy of what can, at best, be loosely termed as a capitalist, free market framework remained untested in practice. The party’s economic ideology and its articulation were limited to mainly critiquing the Nehruvian model from the fringes of the political spectrum. The BJP’s flirting with Gandhian socialism did not last for more than a few months after its founding. In economic policy, the party mainly adopted ‘Neti Neti (Not this, Not this’), without articulating what was its own ‘Niti (policy)’.

The issues that catapulted the party on to the centre stage of the country’s political discourse and then to the seats of power both in the Centre and in various States had little to do with the articulation of an economic road map and its endorsement by the electorate. Nor did the economic direction the country ought to take figure as a serious point of debate and discussion at any point in the highest platforms of the party. So much so that when, for the first time, a dyed-in-the-wool non-Congressman headed the government from 1998 to 2004, no significant departures were initiated in economic policy.

The party’s campaign pitch, ‘India Shining’, under the Vajpayee government failed to impress the voters. That was mainly because the people had not identified the party with any distinct economic philosophy or architecture that they could relate to. Therefore, it is not surprising that the development and economy pitch let down the party in the 2004 general election. The present leadership of the party is perhaps sharply aware of it. It took care not to offer the economic performance of its government as a claim for re-election. It instead chose, wisely, a muscular political, nationalist, security platform.


Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman's Reaction  

“From 2014 to 2019, "we have done fundamental reforms,” said Nirmala Sitharaman, the Finance Minister when asked about her husband's article. Ms Sitharaman went on to list measures like the Goods and Services Tax, Aadhaar and the delivery of cooking gas.

The Rao-Singh policy

The essential element in the present economic quandary is the BJP’s unwillingness to take its eye off the Nehruvian policy framework ball, which it continues to critique. That ball was taken out of the court in 1991 itself. The path-breaking repositioning ushered in by P.V. Narasimha Rao and his economic amanuensis Manmohan Singh remains unchallenged even today. Almost every political party that formed the government, took part in governance, or lent outside support to the government at the Centre since then embraced that repositioning.

The Rao-Singh policy scaffolding remained largely unaltered in the last quarter century. The Congress came to terms with the repudiation of Nehruvian economics by erasing Rao’s memory from its organisational hard disk. But it still kept its connect with the 1991 shift by retaining Dr. Singh. It thus came to terms with the dismounting from the Nehruvian ‘commanding heights of the economy’. It did not flinch from anointing Dr. Singh as its Prime Minister in 2004. 

A Different Turn 

Yet the BJP continues to attack the Nehruvian economic framework. The party think tank fails to realise that the attack remains more a political assault and can never graduate to an economic critique. The agenda to construct an alternative to it or co-opt the one that was constructed did not become an urgent need. Constructs such as ‘Integral Humanism’ could not be rendered into practical policy initiatives in the modern market-driven, globalised world.

The BJP could, therefore, have released itself from that limiting agenda by wholly embracing and even owning the Rao-Singh economic architecture. Sardar Patel, the Congressman the Gandhi dynasty marginalised, could become an icon in the BJP’s political project. Similarly Rao, another Congressman detested and humiliated by the dynasty, could become a robust underpinning for its economic architecture.

The BJP has not challenged or rejected Rao’s 1991 architecture. A full-fledged embrace and an aggressive pursuit of it even now could provide the BJP and the government led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi a lodestar to steer the economy out of the choppy waters it is in at present. That architecture could help the BJP remove the present infirmity in its economic thinking. Otherwise, macroeconomic thought leadership will continue to be offered to the BJP by the shouting analysts on television and in WhatsApp forwards.

(Parakala Prabhakar is former Communications Adviser to the Government of Andhra Pradesh and is Managing Director of RightFOLIO, a knowledge enterprise based in Hyderabad.)


Born 2 Jan 1959; MA, MPhil from JNU; Ph.D from London School of Economics; An Indian political economist, pol itical commentator; Served as Communications Advisor, held a cabinet rank position in AP Gov between July 2014 and June 2018; Presented current affairs programmes, Pratidhwani and Namaste Andhra Pradesh on local TV channels;  A former spokesman and one of the founding general secretaries of Praja Rajyam Party; Former spokesperson of the Andhra unit of the BJP (in 2000s). 

Parakala completed his Ph.D at the London School of Economics. He submitted a thesis titled "Security Doctrines and Foreign Policy Behaviour; A Study of Brazil, Ghana and Indonesia". He worked on his thesis in the International Relations Department under the supervision of Christopher Coker. Before joining the LSE, he went to Jawaharlal Nehru University (School of International Studies) for his MA and MPhil degrees.

Parakala was appointed Communications Advisor with a Cabinet Rank in the N Chandrababu Naidu led Andhra Pradesh Government on June 8, 2014. Parakala established the communications network for the new state. He created systems and structures that not only communicated the point of view of the government to the people, but also collected dependable feedback from the people and conveyed it to the government leaders. Government schemes and programmes were clearly and creatively explained to the people. Social media was introduced into every department of the government. Parakala since the beginning was against the idea of dividing the state of Andhra Pradesh.

The Parakala family was closely associated with P. V. Narasimha Rao, with Prabhakar's father being a close political associate of Rao. Narasimha Rao assigned the task of conceiving, designing and building a grand institution to perpetuate the memory of Rajiv Gandhi. He made Parakala as Officer on Special Duty to oversee the implementation of the project 'Rajiv Gandhi National Institute for Youth Development (RGNIYD). Parakala was nominated by the Congress High Command to represent the Congress Party at the French Communist Party's Plenary in Paris.

Inner party squabbles and bickerings led to Parakala's exit from the Congress Party. He joined the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in late 1997. BJP hardly had a presence in the state and especially in West Godavari District. He contested the ensuing 1998 Lok Sabha election from Narasapur Lok Sabha constituency, and not surprisingly, lost. He played an active role in the party affairs, became a spokesperson of the state unit, and went on to become a member of the BJP's national economic cell that guided the party's economic policy. He was also made a member of a task force of the Planning Commission of India that formulated the Xth Fiver Year Plan.

Parakala quit as Advisor to the Govt as soon as the leader of the opposition made a critical comment on his continuance in the govt in the wake of TDP breaking its alliance with BJP as Parakala's wife happens to be a minister in the NDA govt in the center.

See this story on IOP FACEBOOK - https://bit.ly/2SlmpLA

IOP ON FACEBOOK - https://bit.ly/2SlmpLA


(Onkareshwar Pandey is Founder, Editor in Chief & CEO, Indian Observer Post and former Senior Group Editor- Rashtriya Sahara (Hindi & Urdu) and also former Editor, (News), ANIhttp://bit.ly/2mh7hih)


With 3 Rear Cameras and Night Mode, iPhone 11 Pro launched

By Dr. Darshani PRIYA - https://bit.ly/2kaJ6CW

UAE Mourns Sad Demise of Veteran Indian, Who Brought Electricity to Dubai 

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2kn906L

Donot Waste Food, Conserve Energy and Water: PM Modi

By Dr. Arun Kumar - https://bit.ly/30Z22Uv

Fly 8 Times Faster than Sound, 10 Times Faster than a Current Aircraft

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2Zk0rN4

Several Airlines Ban Apple Macbook Pro Laptops over Fire Concerns

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2L54Avu

UAE Mourns Sad Demise of Veteran Indian, Who Brought Electricity to Dubai 

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2kn906L

The Lamp of Liberty Could Not Shine Bright For Chidambaram
By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/30zsxAo

She Shakti: Celebration of Women Empowerment By Dr. Meenu Kumar

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2Kv5OjW

The Story of Alaíde Foppa, Who Initiated Women’s Forum through Radio UNAM

By Didhiti Ghosh, IOP Bureau Chief, Kolkata - https://bit.ly/2lIA3JJ

Garment Industry Losing Female Force; Reason Includes Sexual Harassment

By Anita Tripathi, Woman Thought Leader - https://bit.ly/2lI3POJ

Indian Author Shweta's Short Story Wins Editor's Choice Award

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2m1pTnL

Stree-Shakti cannot re-emerge without improving their conditions: Dr. Gopal

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2kwhTuD

Women groups demand passage of long-pending Women’s Reservation Bill

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2k70qJ9

A Literary Evening in London with Kamla Dutt and Urmila Jain

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2Zh90o0

Advani Launches Bad Man’s Good Biography in Delhi

By Darshani PRIYA https://bit.ly/2YxntyI

‘Dil Cheez kya hai' Ke Composer Khayyam Ko Aap Jan Lijiye

By Dr. Darshani Priya https://bit.ly/2TKBkwU

Meet-up Celebrating Motherhood by Mintlime

By Rumi Borah - https://bit.ly/2kmFZYU  

The Craft Project by Cocoa and Jasmine: An Amazing Work 

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2DQgYvE

Mesmerizing K-POP Performances of the Year #LGKPOP2019

By Ritika PANDEY https://bit.ly/2Oro2GD

Exclusive Interview with ICCR Regional Director (Kolkata) Gautam De

By Didhiti Ghosh, Bureau Chief (Kolkata), IOP - https://bit.ly/2kAya1J

Dr. Bindeshwar Pathak: India’s Living Legend and Golden Signature

By Onkareshwar Pandey - https://bit.ly/2lEizye

Dr. Kamla Dutt: Who Doesn’t Accept the Pseudo-Classification of Pravasi Sahitya

By Onkareshwar Pandey https://bit.ly/2lI4GyW

Drug Trafficking in West Bengal, Higher than Afghanistan

By Didhiti Ghosh - https://bit.ly/2m5jVCt

Exclusive Interview with Painter and Poet Turned Politician Jogen Chowdhury 

By Didhiti Ghosh - https://bit.ly/2lZFMuR

IOP ON FACEBOOK - https://bit.ly/2SlmpLA


Contact us for:

INDIAN OBSERVER POST (IOP) is a Class, Creative, and Constructive News platform which publishes ONLY exclusive and Special News / Views / Interviews / Research Articles / Analysis / Columns / Features and Opinions on the national and international issues, politics, security, energy, innovation, infrastructure, rural, health, education, women, and entertainment. www.indianobserverpost.com 


INDIAN OBSERVER POST (IOP) is a Class, Creative, and Constructive News platform which publishes ONLY exclusive and Special News / Views / Interviews / Research Articles / Analysis / Columns / Features and Opinions on the national and international issues, politics, security, energy, innovation, infrastructure, rural, health, education, women, and entertainment. Email – editor@indianobserverpost.com

INDIAN OBSERVER POST (Eng) -www.indianobserverpost.com

INDIAN OBSERVER POST (Hindi) -www.indianobserverpost.in

IOP ON FACEBOOK - https://bit.ly/2SlmpLA

IOP TEAM BUREAUS & WRITERS - https://bit.ly/2LxOU2I


(Onkareshwar Pandey is Founder, Editor in Chief & CEO, Indian Observer Post and former Senior Group Editor- Rashtriya Sahara (Hindi & Urdu) and also former Editor, (News), ANI. http://bit.ly/2mh7hih Email - SMS- 9910150119)





Browse By Tags